Wednesday, April 10, 2019

The Good Neighbor: The Life and Work of Fred Rogers by Maxwell King


Title: The Good Neighbor: The Life and Work of Fred Rogers
Author: Maxwell King
Pages: Audiobook
Finished: April 9, 2019

First Sentence: Fred Rogers had given some very specific instructions to David Newell, who handled public relations for the PBS children's show Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood.

Summary: Most Americans in their 30s and older know who Mr. Rogers was. They may remember watching his show. Perhaps they know him from all the memes discussing how amazing he was. But one thing is certain, many people can probably sing a phrase from "Won't You Be My Neighbor?" Or maybe that's just me. But Mr. Rogers was more than just a man making a television show for children. He specialized in music and in child development for early childhood. This is his story.

Thoughts: This is a really tough review to write. First off, I love Mr. Rogers. I think the work he did was really amazing. I chose this book because I'm frustrated. It's 2019 and we have a president who seems to want to watch the world burn. Life feels pretty hopeless. I've brought one child into this world, and I'd like to bring another one in, but I regularly wonder if I'm doing them a disservice as climate change. I thought reading about Mr. Rogers would be a breath of fresh air. Here was a man who lived solely to help children navigate the crazy map of life.

And what I learned about Rogers was really interesting. He was deeply religious, but very authentic in that religious belief. Though a devout Presbyterian, he took spiritual teachings from all the world's religions and incorporated them into his life. He used many of those values in his television shows, but in such a way that it didn't feel prosylityzing. I am a life long atheist, and I deeply respect his religious views. I never once felt preached to.

I also had no idea that he was a music major in college who then discovered children's development. That's basically the same path I went on. I studied in school to be a music teacher ind the public schools, but quickly realized I couldn't do that and ended up in a library where I do a lot with child development. There was something really wonderful in finding that out about Mr. Rogers.

I also was very interested in the making of his television shows. The Children's Corner and then the various iterations of Mr. Rogers Neighborhood. Knowing how he managed to touch children so well. I even picked up a couple new skills to try myself in interacting with kids at work. They're amazing.

Because this was an audiobook, I'd like to review the narrator. LeVar Burton of Star Trek: The Next Generation and The Reading Rainbow fame narrated. He's a fantastic narrator. He keeps the book moving forward (necessary for this one) and he sounds super enthusiastic as he goes. I definitely appreciated having him as a narrator.

But then there's the writing. And this is where the book faltered for me. First of all, the author was super repetitious. Information kept coming back chapter after chapter that I already knew from earlier chapters. It almost felt as though each chapter was written separately and then at no point were they edited to avoid the repetition. On top of it, we were often given a lot of information about adjacent material that felt unnecessary to the book. For example, when Fred Rogers decided to go into television, we ended up with a whole lot of exposition as to how a television works, how it's made, and the workings of NBC. I just didn't care.

Because of this, I was grateful that I was listening to this book as it meant I could "zone out" when I didn't care about the material. That being said, even with his excellent narration skills, LeVar Burton couldn't fully keep the book moving forward.

The information of Fred Rogers life was fantastic, but it didn't outweigh the poor writing of this biography. Which is sad, because Fred Rogers deserved a much better biography than this.

Read for the family book discussion.

Monday, April 8, 2019

Wonder by R. J. Palacio


Title: Wonder
Author: R. J. Palacio
Pages: 311
Finished: April 7, 2019

First Sentence: I know I'm not an ordinary ten-year-old kid.

Summary: August Pullman, who's been home schooled for most of his life, is starting middle school this year. Only August Pullman isn't your typical ten-year-old boy. He suffers from a severe facial deformity. So navigating the hell that is middle school is about ten times as terrifying for him.

Thoughts: I tried to read this book about five years ago when it was all the rage. I couldn't do it. So many books on the Caudill List that year and the year before were about kids with some sort of disability being bullied and then overcoming it. I just couldn't read another one. Particularly because, as someone who was bullied as a kid, I know the bullies basically NEVER learn.

Anyway, the movie a while ago, and I ended up watching it for work. I LOVED the movie. I mean, the Auggie story was what it was. But I was really in for the affection the kids were showing each other. For some reason I was getting a Gordie and Chris vibe from Stand By Me between Auggie and Jack.

So because I saw this movie of kids being unashamed of showing affection for each other, I was willing to try the book again.

It was fine. Not quite as horrific as I remember. In general, I feel Auggie is too well adjusted and the kids basically get over their fears and meanness too much.

I also preferred the Julian story in the movie over the book. But from what I understand, there's a missing chapter there that we will get later.

Definitely a book to recommend to kids who like Contemporary fiction particularly about kids overcoming difficulties and bullies. Still not my cup of tea.


EDITED TO ADD: I checked out the book Auggie and Me which includes three novellas: The Julian Chapter, Pluto, and Shingaling. The Julian Chapter is basically the story of Wonder from Julian's perspective. Hm... I can see how the movie took elements of this story and added it to the film. Many people said that they felt this story exonerated Julian somewhat. I didn't see it that way. The kid had HORRIBLE parents who only cared about status. They didn't really teach him anything helpful. And I don't feel that they or he handled the situation with Auggie well at all. I see he had a phobia to scary faces, but his mom clearly wasn't listening when they were told about it because there was no attempt to deal with it. I guess what I'm trying to say is, I'm glad Julian realized he was being a bully, but I'm glad that it took a long time for him to feel any remorse for what he did.

I skipped over Pluto. It's a story about his friend Christopher from before he goes to Beecher Prep. I didn't care about this kid, so I didn't bother reading.

Shingaling follows Charlotte's storyline through Beecher Prep fifth grade. Boy did that girl have a lot going on. I liked having a bit more information to the story, but in general, I still don't find the books to be something I enjoy reading. 

Monday, April 1, 2019

2019 Goals Quarterly Check-in

  1. Read 52 Books - Progress: 14 / 52 
  2. Finish my Lord of the Rings in Chronological Order project - Progress: 41% 
    Thoughts: Coming back into this project in earnest, I can say without a doubt, I enjoy the stories more when I'm reading through rather than skipping around. I know for the purpose of this project, it's to make sure you have the chronology of what's going on when, but I keep forgetting what's going in in each history. For example, Galadriel's story spans the First, Second, and Third ages. So I keep reading about it in tiny chunks separated by many other bits of information. I forget what's happening. I'm going to keep reading the way I should for the chronology to work out, but if I ever decide to read all the supplemental materials again, I'll do it in a slightly different manner. 
  3. Back to the Classics - Progress: 2 / 12
    Thoughts: I haven't been as impressed with my choices so far. Pinocchio is just as weird as you'd expect, and Years of Grace was disappointing. It started out okay, but fell out of favor for me about halfway through. Hopefully some of my other books will be better.
  4. To Be Read Challenge - Progress: 0 / 12
    Thoughts: Hmm... apparently I need to prioritize a few of these.
  5. Newford Part 1 - Progress: 2 / 12
    Thoughts: Dreams Underfoot is such a lovely short story collection. I've enjoyed the two books I've read so far for this challenge, and am really looking forward to the rest.
  6. Austen Challenge - Progress: 1 / 7
    Thoughts: I love Austen, so there's really not much more to say other than what was already in my review.
  7. Year of Wonder - Progress: 90 / 365
    Thoughts: It's really interesting listening to the various tunes here. There are so many I've never heard before. And while I'm not a fan of everything, I'm really enjoying the process of actively listening to music again. It's been so long since I've done so. 
  8. Other Books Read: 8 
Top 3 Books This Quarter

Austen, Jane - Sense and Sensibility
de Lint, Charles - Dreams Underfoot
Arden, Katherine - The Winter of the Witch

Much of my reading was derailed by two things: First, reading books for other areas of my life that have nothing to do with the challenges (family book discussion and books for work). Second, I started running a Dungeons and Dragons campaign and had to learn how to DM - thus I'm reading various manuals, reading various campaigns, watching various playthroughs, reading various message boards... and in all of this, my normal reading has been put on hold. I hope to get back on track in the second quarter of the year, though it looks as though I will not be necessarily finishing my challenges this year. Right now I'm planning to read primarily books from my Back to the Classics challenge, To Be Read Challenge, and Newford Challenge as well as keeping up with Lord of the Rings.

Sunday, March 31, 2019

Year of Wonder March Check In

This month brought quite a number of new pieces to me with varying degrees of success. Much of it was folk based which I really appreciated. Most of my favorite pieces of classical music are based off folk tunes. There were also a number of modern pieces which were... interesting. I find it interesting to learn about them, but I don't always enjoy listening to them. The other portion of this month was music that was just there. It was fine to listen to, but I felt rather apathetic about it. 

Thoughts on specific pieces below:

Ar hyd y Nos - All through the Night - Traditional Welsh: Beautiful piece of music that I wasn't even aware was Welsh. I didn't come across it until college when we had to show that we could play piano and sing at the same time. This was one of the pieces. 

Missa prolationum 1: Kyrie Eleison I by Johannes Ockeghem - One thing I've learned during this process is that I LOVE the various Masses we've listened to. Apparently I need to add more of those to my daily listening.

Carmen Suite no., 3: Intermezzo by Georges Bizet - I played this in high school! Such lovely music!

Symphony no. 1 in D major, op. 25 ('Classical') 1: Allegro by Sergei Prokofiev - So far, I've been really impressed with the Prokofiev I've heard in this exercise. Other than Peter and the Wolf and his Romeo and Juliet suite, I had never heard anything else by him. But this solidifies the idea that I need more of him in my life. 

Zigeunerweisen, op. 20 by Pablo de Saraste - one of the folk tunes turned classical! This one is super dramatic. You can really imagine Paganini playing this.

Libertango by Astor Piazzolla - Latin music infused with jazz. 

Cello Suite No. 1 in G Major 1: Prelude by J. S. Bach - It occurs to me that I've never heard the rest of this suite, only the first movement. 

Overture from La clemenza di Tito, K. 621 by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - I'm not a fan of Mozart, but this piece definitely intrigued me. I've never seen this opera, or even heard of it. Time to do some more research.

Wednesday, March 27, 2019

Lord of the Rings Challenge March Update

** Reminder this is all part of my reading the Lord of the Rings in chronological order as found here. There may be spoilers to either The Hobbit or the Trilogy in these posts. Read at your own peril.

The vast majority of this month focused on the Hobbit, so this will read more as a review of that novel rather than notes of my journey.

Most people know the story of The Hobbit. Gandalf marks Bilbo as a thief and a number of Dwarfs have a party at his house. There, they ask him to come on an adventure to steal back their homelands from the evil dragon Smaug. 

Bilbo travels with them, encountering trolls, goblins, Wood Elves, and of course the greed of anyone who suddenly finds themselves surrounded by gold. 

Thoughts: The first time I heard The Hobbit was when I was 8 or 9 and my dad read it to us before bed. I adored it. The next time I read it was sometime around high school when the Fellowship of the Ring came out. I listened to it once more via audiobook and then didn't touch any of the series again. So I was looking forward to it this time around.

I was really grateful to have some of the backstory as to why Gandalf A) came with them and B) kept disappearing. I know it's not crucial to the story, but I never really understood why he'd gone with the dwarfs in the first place. Understanding that part of his reasoning was to keep Smaug and Sauron from colluding together helped.

As to the story itself, I found it much sadder than I remember. I always forget about post Smaug. Up until high school, I thought the book ended with killing Smaug. The trolls, goblins, Rivendell, and the woodelves were way more impressionable to me than post Smaug. So when Thorin falls pray to the Dragongreed and the dwarfs bar anyone else from coming in, I just felt... depressed. And the deaths at the end affected me more than I remember. 

The books was interspersed with other material a couple of times, primarily the bit about the Quest for Erebor and a little more knowledge about the Rings of Power. 

After finishing the Hobbit, we learn of the rising of Denethor the II as Steward of Gondor, of Aragorn and some of his doings including becoming friends with Gandalf and becoming bethrothed to Arwen, and we learn a bit more about Saruman and the Palantiri at Orthanc.

Next month, I should be starting Fellowship of the Ring.

Finishing The Hobbit also means I've finished another book on my Classics Club list.

Wednesday, March 20, 2019

Small Animals: Parenthood in the Age of Fear by Kim Brooks


Title: Small Animals: Parenthood in the Age of Fear
Author: Kim Brooks
Pages: 233
Finished: March 20, 2019

First Sentence: It happened in the parking lot of a strip mall during the first week of March 2011, my last morning in Virginia, at the end of a visit with my parents. 

Summary: Kim Brooks left her 4-year-old in a car on a mild day in a safe town while she went in to buy headphones. When she came back out, he was still happily playing on his iPad. What she didn't know was that a "good Samaritan" had filmed her kid in the car and called the police who issued a warrant for her arrest. What follows is a look at how fear has changed parenting.

Thoughts: Content-wise, I really liked this book. I am not an anxious parent. On the whole, I believe my kid is relatively safe at the park without me hanging next to her the whole time. I believe that I can be in a completely different room of the house than her without it being a problem. A couple weeks ago, an internet scare went around. While everyone was freaking out, I actually fact checked the claims, realized they were not true, and that the reality was A) not as bad as everyone thought it was and B) easily mitigated. But when I mentioned this, I was maligned for not taking it seriously... Also I was apparently victim blaming by suggesting parents monitor their kids' internet usage.

So as she talked, I felt myself agreeing. There were many things I related with. The idea that fathers can get away with plenty of things that are no issue, but when a mom does them, it's suddenly neglect. The idea that people are afraid of things that are incredibly unlikely to happen, but they have no issue with things like their 16-year-olds driving. That by keeping our kids so safe, we're not allowing them to be kids.She also had a lot to say about how she was making choices thanks to the freedom of living in America. But she also realized that if she lived somewhere else that had socialized healthcare, socialized childcare, and reasonable parental leave, she would have been free to make more choices. Her points were so spot on.

But I disliked her writing style. The frame was the true story of her arrest experience of leaving her kid in the car and the after effects of that. So she'd tell a part of the story and then present an argument. Many of the arguments were presented but no conclusion was made which was frustrating. And in general, this author is a very anxious parent. While reading the book, I felt my own anxiety rising which was beyond frustrating because I'm not anxious. In fact, I found myself more anxious about other parents than I am about my kid.

In general, the information is good. I think the human aspect of her experience makes this a bit more accessible than some of the other books warning the same things, but it is rather difficult if you already have anxiety issues.

Sunday, March 17, 2019

Years of Grace by Margaret A. Barnes


Title: Years of Grace
Author: Margaret Ayer Barnes
Pages: 581
Finished: March 17, 2019

First Sentence: Little Jane Ward sat at her father's left hand at the family breakfast table, her sleek, brown pigtailed head bent discreetly over her plate.

Summary: Years of Grace follows the life of Jane Ward as she grows from a teenager to a middle aged woman in Chicago during the late Victorian era through to the 1920s. Summarizing this is more than a bit difficult as really the book is a life story and reflection of Jane set agains the backdrop of Chicago. Suffice it to say, she grows, she loves, and she lives to be disappointed.

Thoughts: The novel started strong for me. I spent a good deal of time googling various places mentioned to try and get a sense of where Jane Ward was as she talked about places. It was neat to see Chicago from a historical sense. And I liked the story. Of course it was fairly easy going. Upper class people with upper class problems.

The book slowed for me when it became clear that Jane was going to have an affair. Of course, it'd been foreshadowed in the first and second parts when she talked about Flora's mother, but I didn't want her to. And I guess, in a way, she didn't really.

The fourth part got into this massive discussion of the differences in generations as Jane realized she was different from her kids and she would never understand the next generation.

I found Jane to be rather blah to be honest. She seemed to be either completely unaware of things she should be aware of, or willfully ignoring them. Particularly Jimmy and then Cicily and Albert. I don't think she handled many situations as well as she could have. And in the end, she seemed rather melancholy. It seemed she lived her whole life with this expectation that ended up being completely and totally wrong.

For me, the best part of this novel was the Chicago landmarks. I never realize just how much Chicago pride I have until I see it in books or movies. I really enjoyed looking up the street Jane lived on as a child and finding out it's now Michigan Ave. I don't think I'd say this book is something I'll ever read again, but it wasn't odious. I just wasn't as into it as I wanted to be.

Read for Back to the Classics as a book set somewhere I live.