A Study in Scarlet by Arthur Conan Doyle

Title: A Study in Scarlet

Author: Arthur Conan Doyle

Pages: 142

Finished: March 1, 2021

First Sentence: In the year 1878 I took my degree of Doctor of Medicine of the University of London, and proceeded to Netley to go through the course prescribed for surgeons in the army.

Summary: Dr. Watson, just home from Afghan wars, finds himself in need of a roommate. He takes up lodgings with the enigmatical Sherlock Holmes who, it turns out, is a consulting detective. Watson writes up the strange case of a dead man found in an abandoned house and how Holmes solved it.

Thoughts: Reading the source material for Sherlock Holmes is always interesting because I came to the source material after I was already aware of the character. My first remembered experience with Sherlock Holmes is from the Disney movie The Great Mouse Detective. Following that, I saw some various BBC versions - some actual Sherlock Holmes adaptations. At one point we listened to some Sherlock Holmes audiobooks on a family vacation. I remember the Speckled Band. Then there's all the various movies, Sherlock and Elementary, Data pretending to be Sherlock Holmes on Star Trek. 

All that to say, I've seen so many Sherlock Holmes characterizations that coming back to the source was interesting. The book itself is broken into two parts. The first part is the set up of meeting Sherlock, the mystery, and the investigation leading to an arrest. The second part begins in America with two people on death's door being saved by Mormons. It was such a jarring switch that I actually thought the ebook I was reading had a different story in it. Nope, all good. It's just the context for why the murderer became a murderer. After we get all that context, we get the wrap up of how Holmes solved the case and the aftermath. 

Weirdly enough, because I'm more familiar with pop culture Holmes, I found myself comparing the original to what I know. He's a cocky jackass for sure. I'm not sure if I'll continue reading more Holmes. 

This does count as one book off my Classics Club list and I'll be using it for a category in Back to the Classics, though I'm not yet sure which one.

Master of Poisons by Andrea Hairston

Title: Master of Poisons

Author: Andrea Hairston

Pages: 507

Finished: February 24, 2021

First Sentence: We are more likely to deny truth than admit grave error and change our minds. 

Summary: Poison desert ravages the land. Djola, Master of Poisons and right-hand mand of the Emporer is banished to live a life among pirates for suggesting people work together and those higher up make sacrifices to solve the problem. Awa, a young smoke-walker travels her own road of danger as she goes against what the Empire believes to be true.  

Thoughts: This is a slow burn book. I started it at the beginning of January and it took close to two months to read. I found this book while looking up fantasy based on African legends. I don't know enough of any African folklore to say whether this one followed any, but I was definitely expecting more along the lines of Redemption in Indigo. 

This is epic fantasy told in a style that I imagine is more similar to oral storytelling. The sentences have a cadence unlike any I've read recently. It took a while to wrap my head around, but once I got there, I was fine with it. Time tends to jump too. The book starts with many chapters that take place in one day, then suddenly jump years. It's jarring at first but you get there in the end. There's also a bit of a learning curve with this world's language. Most fantasy I read is decidedly western in its setting. There's familiarity in the creatures and the names used. It took a bit more time to understand the setting here as well.

Mainly, the book itself was oddly paced. It mostly alternated between Djola's and Awa's points of view. The first few chapters were quick and I was on board with what was happening. But when Djola's point of view chapters were stuck in his eight-year pirate journey where he just felt sorry for himself, I floundered. He wasn't a particularly likeable character, which doesn't kill a book for me, but his self-pity was tough to take at the moment when I was reading it. 

Awa was more likable in that first half, though as her story became what it was and she became angry and disillusioned with the world, I found her fairly tough to deal with as well. The story itself picked up when Djola's and Awa's paths finally converged at which point the final 200 pages were a quick finish. 

The setting was an interesting take on climate change. This was man-made climate change though through environmental means and magic. It mirrored a lot of what we see happening now with those on top not only being unwilling to try anything new but also digging in deeper with harmful practices that artificially keep the poison desert away. Hezram's dream/nightmare gates were especially distressing and poignant. 

I also appreciated that the book didn't end with a complete turnaround. Awa, Djola, and their allies didn't save the world. They just managed to figure out a less-harmful temporary solution so they could breathe and figure out a more permanent solution. 

This book definitely falls on the epic side of the fantasy continuum. I'd recommend it to people who enjoy long sagas such as Lord of the Rings or the Eragon series especially if they're looking for something a little less white male centric. While the empire itself is very patriarchal, there are matricarchial societies within the Empire and there's a subset of people called the Green Elders who live a life as non-binary individuals. Of course, both the matriarchial societies and the Green Elders are persecuted for these things, but, as is usually the case when people want to make changes in the world, they play a large role in the climax of the story and the band-aid solution to get some breathing room.